Sarah Turner on the money beliefs that followed her to 8 figures
Money doesn’t just live in your bank account — it lives in your nervous system, your upbringing, your relationships, and even tiny habits (anyone else leave the tags on new clothes for way too long?).
In this episode, Emily and Cassidy sit down with Sarah Turner — their mentor, the reason they met, and a major influence on how they think about money, work, and freedom. Sarah shares what it was like going from writing for pennies at content mills to building an eight-figure business, and why that kind of financial success doesn’t automatically erase your scarcity mindset.
The big theme running through this conversation is curiosity — noticing what money brings up in your body, asking where it came from, and choosing what you want to carry forward instead of living on autopilot.
Episode timestamps
[00:00] Meet Sarah Turner — mentor, entrepreneur, and the woman who brought Cassidy and Emily together
[03:00] What it looks like to live authentically (and why “bloom where you’re planted” doesn’t work for everyone)
[05:00] How money changed for Sarah when she went from earning pennies at content mills to building an 8-figure business
[08:00] Stepping back from work, shifting identities, and the emotions that come up when your partner becomes the breadwinner
[12:00] A debate about “manufacturing scarcity,” and why Sarah refuses to use stress as a spending strategy
[15:00] The limiting beliefs that kept money tied to morality, greed, and gender expectations
[17:00] Defining mindset work in plain language, including what helped Sarah most[22:00] Growing up with a frugal financial advisor dad, and the confusing messages that can create
[31:00] How to build “proof” when you feel overwhelmed, plus the idea of doing money admin with friends
[39:00] Lifestyle creep, big mortgages, and why feeling calm matters more than looking successful
[46:00] Finding your values through patterns, discomfort, and a look at what you’re actually spending
Money beliefs don’t automatically change when your income does
Sarah is very clear about something most of us learn the hard way: earning more money doesn’t automatically rewrite your money beliefs.
If you grew up with scarcity, anxiety, or moral messaging about money (“people with money are greedy,” “wanting more is wrong,” “spending on yourself is irresponsible”), those scripts can stick around even when your reality changes. The difference is that once you’re aware of them, you can recognize the pattern faster.
A small but powerful example from Sarah’s own life: ripping the tags off clothes right away. It sounds silly until you’ve been the person who keeps tags on “just in case,” because finality feels unsafe.
That’s one of the most validating takeaways from this episode — you don’t need to “fix yourself” for having old money reflexes. You just need to notice them, name them, and decide what you want to do next.
How money beliefs show up in marriage
Sarah’s in the middle of something she never thought she’d do — stepping back from work while her kids are little (and expecting a third baby soon). Financially, she’s not in crisis — but emotionally, the shift still kicks up old beliefs.
For the first time in their relationship, her husband is the breadwinner, and Sarah notices herself slipping into a familiar, uncomfortable role: feeling like she has to ask permission, justify spending, and brace for judgment that isn’t actually there.
She tells a story about wanting to hire musicians to bring instruments for her son’s birthday (because he’s obsessed with music). The quote comes in, and she bursts into tears — not because it’s objectively unaffordable, but because it feels like she’s about to have a conversation with her dad.
This is such a good reminder that money triggers are often time travel. You’re reacting to a memory, a dynamic, or a rule you absorbed long ago — not the person in front of you.
If you’ve ever felt shame for being “too emotional” about money, I want you to hear this clearly: money is emotional because it touches everything, including your identity.
Scarcity isn’t Sarah’s favorite budgeting strategy
Sarah shares a conversation with her husband that’s pretty funny — and relatable.
They’re discussing how to allocate money (taxes, investments, expenses, the practical stuff), and he suggests paying down the mortgage so they’ll have less in checking and feel a sense of scarcity — which, in his mind, will help them spend less.
Sarah’s response is basically: absolutely not, I refuse to participate in manufactured stress.
A lot of people treat anxiety like it’s a helpful financial tool. (Side note: Cassidy admitted to having similar thought patterns.)
But “stress” is not the same thing as “responsibility.”
If you don’t have a spending problem, creating scarcity to prevent one isn’t discipline — it’s emotional self-punishment disguised as a plan.
A healthier approach Sarah models is this: Assume you can be responsible without scaring yourself into it. Build systems, talk openly, and choose clarity over mind games.
The limiting belief that blocks so many women
Sarah isn’t shy about sharing the limiting beliefs she grew up with and later had to unlearn:
wanting money is greedy
having “enough” money isn’t virtuous
women aren’t supposed to focus on money
If any of those feel familiar, you’re not alone. There are so many cultural storylines where you’re either:
the soulless, overworked, big-money villain, or
the pure-hearted, underpaid good person
(Hallmark movies, anyone?)
Unfortunately, there’s not a lot of cultural scripting for “kind, heart-centered, financially secure, successful, generous person.”
Sarah points out a common emotional disconnect: People want a life with ease, freedom, time, travel, rest, or community — but they want it to be magically unrelated to money. And then they feel ashamed when they realize money buys time.
It’s not bad to want time. It’s not bad to want a life that feels good. And the money conversation gets easier when you stop making it mean something about your character.
What “mindset work” actually looks like in real life
Mindset work can sound like a vague internet phrase, but Sarah grounds it in real actions. As Emily and Cassidy can attest to, mindset work is no small part of what Sarah teaches (because it was such an integral part of her own growth).
Here are some of Sarah’s favorite ways to practice mindset work:
Reading personal development books that address your patterns
Therapy
Nurturing supportive friendships with people who want to grow
Journaling and mindfulness
Writing affirmations
Intentionally rewiring your thoughts by practicing new ones
Most importantly, she emphasizes finding role models who reflect your values.
Not emulating people on Instagram because their life looks cool, but finding examples (IRL, if possible) of good people who have money, boundaries, freedom, and a sense of calm.”
Building confidence when you feel like you have none
If you’re overwhelmed by money and avoiding your bank account, putting off decisions, or feeling frozen — Sarah offers a simple (but not easy) starting point:
Look at it.
Not to shame yourself, but to get grounded in reality.
A lot of financial panic lives in the background like a horror movie soundtrack. You don’t know the numbers, so your brain fills in the blanks with worst-case scenarios. When you actually open the spreadsheet or review the statements, you might still feel a surge of anxiety — but you also get something powerful:
Clarity.
Sarah also shares two strategies that make this doable when your nervous system is screaming:
Make it small. You’re not fixing everything overnight. You’re building proof one micro choice at a time.
Do it with someone else. She loves the idea of “admin night” with friends — wine, snacks, bank accounts open, and mutual moral support while you do the scary stuff.
If you’ve been waiting to feel calm before you look, consider flipping that on its head: You can experience calm because you looked.
The lifestyle creep trap
With the success she’s built, Sarah’s had the chance to be in rooms with lots of high-earning, “successful” business owners. Over the years, she’s learned something surprising: A lot of people making a ton of money are still a financial mess. They look successful, but their expenses are so high they’re trapped.
The bigger the house, the more expensive it is to furnish, maintain, insure, and “keep up” with the neighborhood expectations. If you take on a massive mortgage or fixed costs based on one great year, it can create a hamster wheel you can’t get off.
Sarah’s personal preference is simple and soothing:
Keep expenses reasonable
Don’t push it to the edge
Prioritize being able to sleep at night
She and Cassidy also talk about one of the most stabilizing principles for entrepreneurs: build your baseline around your slow months, not your best months. Let “good months” be extra, not a requirement.
TL;DR
Your money beliefs don’t disappear when you earn more — they just show up in new ways.
Scarcity isn’t a budgeting strategy, and manufacturing stress won’t make you more responsible.
Mindset work can be practical: role models, journaling, affirmations, therapy, and intentional rewiring.
If you feel overwhelmed, start by looking at the numbers — then take tiny, repeatable steps (ideally with support).
Lifestyle creep can trap high earners — and “not stressed” is a valid financial goal.
Resources:
📖 Check our Sarah’s book, Bet On Yourself
💻 Visit Sarah’s website or follow her on Instagram
♥️ If you want to support The Finance Girlies, consider becoming an Insider. For $5 a month ($1.25 per week) you’ll get a monthly bonus episode and help keep the show ad-free. Sign up here.
💌 Did you know we have a weekly newsletter? If you’re only listening to the podcast, you’re missing out on half the fun. Each week, we’ll send you fun stories, resources, and money tips straight to your inbox. Sign up here.
